Timothy Masters — Drawn to Injustice
In February 1987, 15-year-old Timothy Masters was walking to school in Fort Collins, Colorado, when he passed what he believed was a mannequin lying in a field. It was the body of Peggy Hettrick, who had been murdered hours earlier. Police soon focused on Masters because he had not reported what he saw. Yet no physical evidence connected him to the crime: hairs recovered from Hettrick did not match him, fingerprints found in her purse were not his, and searches of his clothes, home, and knife collection found no trace of her blood or hair.
Investigators instead placed heavy emphasis on Masters’s dark drawings and writings. A forensic psychologist who never interviewed him interpreted portions of that artwork as evidence that Masters was reliving the murder. More than a decade after the crime, Masters was arrested, and in 1999 a jury convicted him of murder. He was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.
The case began to unravel after a new defense team reinvestigated it. The team uncovered critical information that had not been provided to the original defense, including evidence concerning other possible suspects. New touch-DNA testing of evidence from the crime scene excluded Masters and pointed elsewhere. On January 22, 2008, a judge vacated his conviction and ordered his immediate release. Prosecutors then dismissed the charge after he had spent nearly a decade in prison.
In June 2011, Colorado Attorney General John Suthers announced that a renewed investigation—including more than 170 interviews, additional DNA analysis, and a review of the crime scene evidence—had concluded that Masters was not involved in Hettrick’s murder. He was officially exonerated. The murder remains unsolved, and Masters’s case endures as a warning about investigative tunnel vision, the misuse of subjective behavioral evidence, and the lasting consequences of failing to disclose evidence that could point away from the accused.
Further reading: 5280 — Presumed Guilty